What is the Best Home Defense Weapon That Will Serve Your Needs?
By: Rob Orgel, Emergency Response Tactical
Let's first be clear on what we're preparing for. You are at a heavy disadvantage if someone is standing at the foot of your bed. Getting your side-arm on your nightstand may be possible, but there might not be many more options at that point. So let's train with a little bit more reality in mind.
Early detection is your best advantage. This means when someone steps foot onto your driveway or property, you know about it and are alerted. If not early detection, a home alarm system will inform you when your front door has been opened at an odd hour of the night.
It is my recommendation that this system tells you not only the home has been breached but where it has been breached. If this information can be given to you audibly, it allows you to focus your eyes and hands on responding to the threat.
Now that we have a clear picture in our minds, how much time do we have to react? Depending on your home layout as well as your property size, this could afford you several minutes or maybe just 30 seconds. Where can we invest that energy in our emergency?
My favorite consideration is, “What can we do before the early detection alarm?” Putting some thought and time into our plan and preparedness can make the difference between night and day. Other than consistent training and range time with Spartan Armor Systems® Steel Targets, this means having your weapon staged in a place that allows quick access, along with a medical kit. This may also include doing a “dry run" of your home. This helps gain an outline for you and your family to respond to this emergency without having to make it up under stress.
There are two examples I like to give as analogies for a carbine versus pistol scenario. Having a carbine is much like having a machete and having a pistol is much like having a toothpick. Where do you intend to poke someone with your toothpick in hopes that they will not swing that machete at you in the process of being poked?
If I’m holding a carbine or shotgun, it’s unlikely that I’m going to stop using it and move to my pistol. How can we chew on this, if you’re in a racecar on lap 410 of 500 and you get a flat tire, are you going to get out and start walking? If forward momentum is your goal then sure, you can walk. But it’s not likely you’re going to win the race.
I think that you should change the tire in the pits and get back to the race. This means conducting a reload or fixing a malfunction on your primary weapon rather than transitioning into your secondary. Certainly, there are exceptions to this rule. But by and large, I want to be in my racecar while everyone else is speeding around the track.
Now that we’re reacting to this emergency, what weapon are we putting in our hands? For many, it’s a pistol. I strongly disagree with this concept. Pistols are great for concealment and ease of carrying. They are not good threat-stopping tools. A far more effective weapon is a carbine or shotgun.
Consider the speed, accuracy, and ballistic capabilities of the long gun and know that they far outweigh the capabilities of a handgun. There are several examples and scenarios you can play out or read in historical events to understand the limitations of a pistol compared to a carbine or shotgun.
Consider your speed and accuracy with your carbine for example. Your ability to make multiple hits across greater distances and in a shorter time. Now consider the ballistic capabilities of a 556 or multiple impacts from buckshot. Not just your ability to effectively engage at the target but the ballistic stopping power and traumatic effect of the different weapons. That should make a very clear point as to why a pistol is for convenience and if I have the option a carbine or shotgun is a far more suitable friend in an emergency.
Now that I have selected a carbine or shotgun instead of my pistol, let’s accompany it with the right gear. It is my theory that a defensive weapon is far more effective with a flashlight attached to it. So as a rule of thumb in my life, I won’t select a weapon to protect me unless it has a flashlight mounted to it.
Next, if I have the time and the training, I want ballistic protection in this emergency. So with the early detection of 60 seconds, I can dawn my body armor, grab my carbine, and check my flashlight and red dot sight before responding to the threat at my front door or in my home.
In summary, I believe in the old adage, “a pistol is for fighting your way to a rifle.” A big part of winning your fight is preparing for your fight. Laying out the proper tools, and accompanying the tools with the correct accessories. This of course is in addition to having a plan and the training to execute your plan so that your family can have the best possible outcome and highest probability of surviving your emergency.
About the Author:
Rob joined the USMC in 2004 with a military occupational specialty of 0311 (Infantry Rifleman). Assigned to 3rd Bn 1st Marines, Rob participated in a deployment to Iraq (OIF-3) as a point man followed by an assignment as Team Leader for the 13th MEU Special Operations Capable to Iraq (OIF-6). In 2007, he joined 1st Marine Regiment and reenlisted to deploy to Afghanistan. InJanuary 2010, Rob was promoted to the rank of Sergeant & continued to serve 1st Marine Regiment for a year-long deployment in Afghanistan. On return from Afghanistan, Rob was assigned to School Of Infantry West to work as a Combat Instructor (CI) for the USMC where he trained thousands of Marines to gain the skills necessary to survive. Rob exited the USMC in 2014 & was immediately picked up by Securing our Country (SOC). As a private military contractor, Rob was responsible for training the specialty teams of operators at the American Embassy in Iraq. Shortly after leaving Contract in 2018, Rob became the Chief Instructor of GPS Defense Sniper School. Rob now gives 100% of his attention to Emergency Response Tactical training all levels over 320 days a year as his passion & full-time job.
You can read his full bio here.